Navigating Narcissistic Behavior while Fostering Accountability 

Handling narcissistic employees can be a real challenge in the workplace. They often exhibit self-centered behavior, lack empathy, and think they’re the center of the universe, which can make work-life difficult for everyone. So, how do we deal with these folks and ensure they’re held accountable while keeping the workplace healthy and productive? Easier said than done, as they have a knack for shirking responsibilities, gaslighting, and throwing others, including their leaders, under the bus.  

But first things first. You have to set your radar to identify the narcissistic behavior in your midst. Not everyone who acts self-centered is a narcissist. Still, there are some obvious telltale signs to look out for, including shameless self-promotion, lack of empathy, manipulating situations and people to get what they want, easily bruised egos, and constant search for the limelight. They also tend to struggle to work well with others, often treating their colleagues as rivals instead of teammates.  

It’s Not Enough to Identify the Behavior 

Once you’ve identified these traits in employees, it’s crucial to think about how to hold them accountable. However, accountability isn’t solely about managing those demonstrating narcissistic tendencies; it extends to all employees. Effective leadership means ensuring that performance management is applied consistently across the board. To rein in narcissistic employees, it’s essential to establish clear rules and boundaries within the workplace. This involves creating a workplace code of conduct that explicitly outlines behavior, performance, and teamwork expectations. Communication plays a pivotal role in this process. It’s imperative that everyone, including individuals exhibiting narcissistic traits, fully comprehends the code of conduct and is aware of the consequences for violating it. 

Moreover, consequences must be clearly defined for undesirable behavior, which could encompass actions like issuing warnings, providing coaching, or, in extreme cases, considering the possibility of termination. Implementing a confidential reporting system is essential to foster a culture of transparency and accountability. This mechanism ensures that all employees feel safe reporting inappropriate behavior. Lastly, fairness is paramount. Leaders must enforce these expectations consistently and impartially across all employees, irrespective of their personality traits or positions within the organization. This consistency promotes a harmonious and productive work environment while addressing the issues posed by narcissistic behavior. 

Feedback as a Tool 

Holding narcissistic employees accountable involves the essential step of providing feedback. This feedback serves as a valuable tool for helping them recognize their shortcomings and find ways to enhance their performance and behavior. To achieve this, it’s crucial to schedule regular performance reviews that cover various aspects, including their overall performance, behavior, and interactions with colleagues. During these feedback sessions, it’s beneficial to use specific examples to illustrate the areas where improvement is needed. Furthermore, it’s essential to emphasize how their behavior impacts not only the team and department but also the entire organization.  

To support their growth and development, consider offering guidance, resources, and relevant training opportunities. Think of this as a chance for them to grow both personally and professionally. Lastly, maintaining thorough records of these feedback sessions, including the issues discussed, planned actions, and deadlines for improvement, can prove invaluable down the line. These records may come in handy when tracking progress or making more informed decisions regarding their accountability. 

Don’t React to Defensive Behavior 

Handling defensive behavior from narcissistic employees is crucial for maintaining accountability. When faced with defensiveness, gaslighting, or confrontational behavior, it’s essential to maintain your composure, as staying calm can help prevent the situation from escalating. Practice active listening by repeating their concerns and acknowledging their feelings before offering a response; this demonstrates that you value their perspective. Shift the focus onto the specific behavior or issue at hand rather than making it personal. Use “I” statements to express your concerns, emphasizing the impact of their actions on the team or organization. Encourage open dialogue and collaboration to address the problem, inviting them to share their thoughts on how to resolve the issue, fostering a sense of ownership in finding solutions.  

In cases where narcissistic behavior persists despite efforts to address it, a progressive discipline approach may be necessary. Progressive discipline involves a series of escalating consequences for repeated rule violations. Begin with a verbal warning, clearly communicating the issue, expectations, and potential consequences of further rule violations. If the problematic behavior continues, escalate to a written warning, documenting their actions, referencing past feedback, and outlining the changes required for improvement. In more severe cases, consider a temporary suspension to underscore the seriousness of the situation and provide the employee with a period of reflection. As a last resort, termination may be necessary if narcissistic behavior continues to disrupt the workplace and negatively affect the organization despite previous interventions. Implementing progressive discipline offers a systematic approach to addressing ongoing issues while providing multiple opportunities for the employee to correct their behavior. 

Maximize Their Talents 

Dealing with narcissistic employees can be challenging, but it’s essential to maintain a healthy workplace and promote accountability. By setting clear expectations, offering feedback, encouraging self-reflection, and fostering a supportive team environment, you can help narcissistic employees become better colleagues and contribute positively to the organization. Remember that holding them accountable is not just about addressing their behavior; it’s also about giving them a chance to grow and change. 


Don’t forget to check out Dismantling Dysfunction, our podcast series for anyone who experiences dysfunction in organizations, leadership, or relationships:

Power Up Your Innate Potential Facebook Group is a private group to help you meet and mingle with other like-minded individuals that are striving to achieve their potential: